For years, a basic set of Black+Decker cordless power tools met my DIY needs. As my projects became more ambitious, I expanded my collection, sticking with the same brand to avoid investing in a new battery platform. However, I recently added a second battery system and realized the significant advantages it offers. This article explores why most DIY enthusiasts would benefit from having at least two 18V/20V tool lineups.
Building Your Initial Cordless Tool Collection
Before diving into a second battery system, let’s address starting your first. Consider your budget, frequency of use, project types, and immediate versus future tool requirements. For occasional use, affordable brands like Craftsman or Porter Cable offer excellent value. A Black+Decker four-tool combo kit can be purchased for around $150, significantly less than comparable sets from premium brands like Makita, Rigid, or DeWalt.
However, for daily or professional use, investing in higher-quality tools with superior power and ergonomics is worthwhile. Research each brand’s offerings to ensure they align with your specific needs. For instance, if you’re restoring a car, an impact ratchet might be essential, so confirm its availability within your chosen system. Also, consider where you typically purchase tools, as retailers often exclusively carry specific brands. Harbor Freight offers Bauer and Hercules, while Menards, The Home Depot, and Lowe’s each have their own exclusive lines. Keep in mind that Craftsman isn’t available at The Home Depot, and Makita isn’t sold at Lowe’s.
Expanding Your Arsenal: When a Second Battery System Makes Sense
While my Black+Decker tools provided reliable service, their limited product range eventually prompted me to explore a second battery system. When my corded DeWalt router broke, finding a replacement part proved impossible. Since Black+Decker doesn’t offer a cordless router, I needed a new battery platform.
Initially, I considered Ryobi due to their extensive tool selection. However, the Ryobi router felt uncomfortable, and given its importance in my woodworking, I opted against it. After researching and testing various options, I chose a DeWalt router, drill/driver set, and oscillating multitool. The power difference between my old drill and the DeWalt was immediately noticeable, solidifying my decision to invest further in DeWalt.
Long-Term Savings with Two Battery Systems
While counterintuitive, owning two battery systems can lead to long-term savings. By diversifying, you gain access to a wider tool selection without needing top-tier versions for every task. For occasional drywall repairs, Ryobi’s $60 rotary cut-out tool is a more practical choice than DeWalt’s $199 equivalent. Similarly, Ryobi’s $150 deep-cut bandsaw offers considerable savings compared to Milwaukee’s $400 model. For infrequent use, sacrificing some power for affordability is often a sensible compromise.
Conclusion: Embracing a Multi-Platform Approach
Adding a second battery system expands your tool options and allows for cost-effective choices based on project needs. While my initial Black+Decker tools remain valuable, integrating DeWalt provides access to specialized tools and increased power. This multi-platform approach empowers DIYers to optimize their tool collection for both performance and budget. Consider your individual requirements and explore the benefits of incorporating a second battery system into your workshop. You might be surprised at the versatility and savings it unlocks.